Quote:

Quote:
Any video documentary material regarding the film, or those associated with it.

For me the addition of "or those associated with it" settles it. That too can mean stuff that isn't necessarily tied to the movie. I have several discs that include featurettes that are purely profiles on a certain actor, producer or director, which are not tied to, nor made to promote any one particular film. So even though they're not about the film they're accompanying, the rule still explicitly says they're "Featurettes". Even though it's not about the film itself, but merely about someone associated with the film. This is no different. It may not be about the film, but about an original song written for the film, so again something associated with it. As the rules clearly declare the former to be a "Featurette", I don't see how the same shouldn't apply here. Either we restrict the use of "Featurette" to be about the disc's main feature only, or we don't - but not a strange mix of things. Since the rules already explicitly allow "associated" material, I honestly don't see how this can be excluded.

Quote:
Quoting DoubleDownAgain:

Quote:
Quoting GSyren:

Quote:
@DoubleDownAgain: "Regarding" and "related" are two different things.

Thanks??   What about 'related'?  I assume you missed that part of the rule?

No, you misread that part of the rule..  The rule uses the word 'regarding', not related.  Regarding means about, related means connected.  Per the rule, the documentary material must be about the film or those associated with it, not about something related to the film or those associated with it.

Quote:
I threw the disc in and watched both the music video and the making of featurette... and guess what,???  The music video contains scenes of the movie.  The making of featurette of the Music Video talks about the film itself, scenes from the movie, how it inspired the song, etc.  If anyone says that the featurette isn't related to the movie they would be 100% wrong.  There is a reason why they put this featurette on the disc, because it IS RELATED to the film.

Nobody is arguing that point, but the rule doesn't say 'related to the film', it says 'regarding the film'.

Quote:
I can understand those that don't want it marked, but please don't ignore the rules just because you don't like them.  Thanks!

Go back and read what the rule actually says, rather than what you think it says, then tell me if this statement still applies. 

Quote:
"Or those associated with it" means people associated with the film, not content associated with the film.

Quote:
Once again:

Quote:
Any video documentary material regarding the film, or those associated with it.

So it's any video documentary material regarding the film, and it's any video documentary material regarding those associated with the film. A "making of" featurette on the film's music video falls under the latter: it's video documentary material regarding those associated with the film.

Quote:
Quoting T!M:

Quote:
Once again:

Quote:
Any video documentary material regarding the film, or those associated with it.

So it's any video documentary material regarding the film, and it's any video documentary material regarding those associated with the film. A "making of" featurette on the film's music video falls under the latter: it's video documentary material regarding those associated with the film.

If the documentary were about the song writing process, like the documentary about the score for The Lord of the Rings, then I would agree.  But the making of a music video for a song, that I don't agree with.

Again, this is just my opinion and you are free to ignore it and check the box, just as I am free to ignore your opinion and not check the box.  I honestly don't see what the big deal is.  Unlike some people here, I am not going to go on a mission to remove all the checks that I don't agree with.  :anxi  ous:

Quote:
The song is in the movie.  The making of the music video is a documentary material associated with the film, hence it is a featurrete by the definition of the rule.  You are wrong, plain and simple.

Quote:
You of course you are free to your opinion.

Quote:
If you had the opinion that 2 + 2 = 5 it'd be your opinion, but you'd also be wrong.

Quote:
I couldn't care less if you agree with it or not, unless of course you are trying to get it into the database.

Quote:
I only responded to your post because you had already stated your opinion, but for some reason felt you had to state it again without adding anything else to the discussion.