I had a no vote for altering the title of this set.  To quote the no vote "from rules: The Edition field is for distinguishing between DVDs, and for indicating special versions and collections."  I always read that as meaning collections such as The Criterion Collection, not to place part of the title of a collection of shorts into that field.  Putting "Ultimate TV Specials Collection" in the edition field, and leaving the title to simply be Peanuts feels so wrong to me, but I'll withdraw if that's the consensus.

So, do you think that "Ultimate TV Specials Collection" goes in the title field, or the edition field?

Quoting GreyHulk:

Quote:
"Peanuts: Ultimate TV Specials Collection" is the Title, as far as I'm concerned.

It's similar to something like "Generic Title: Seasons 1-3". You wouldn't put "Seasons 1-3" into the Edition field.

I would argue it's not similar to it, since the rules specifically state collections go as editions and don't say anything about seasons doing the same.

It's always been my understanding that the edition field was to indicate that a release was part of a collection, such as The Criterion Collection, rather than that it was a collection

For example:

The Criterion Collection



Global Lens Collection



Archive Collection



World Class Cinema Collection



None of these can be part of the title, the Collection is clearly separate.  Unlike the previous examples, where the titles clearly indicate that what is enclosed is itself a collection, rather than a part of one - or that it is the subsequent volume of an ongoing series.

An Edition is to differentiate between otherwise identical releases.

For example, "Anniversary Edition", "Special Collector's Edition" or "Rental Copy".

A "Collection" is basically a Box Set. You wouldn't, or shouldn't, put "Box Set" in the Edition field.

Its all about context, was it contiguous or was it clearly separate from the title.

It reminds me of the discussion on "3D" on the front cover, when Ken Cole confirmed its correct usage in the cover title. For me, the edition needs to be clearly segregated from the title.

That's why I voted YES to title.

Quoting rdodolak:

Quote:
I see this is now OBE, but I agree with you. Unfortunately, some contributors what the database to reflex how they catalog their collection rather than what the actual rules state.

Yeah like people who insist features on the Blu-ray of a UHD/Blu-ray combo belong on the main profile even though that's not what the rules say because that's how they catalog their collection 

and what would you add here ?
I added "Lionsgate Limited 25th Anniversary Uncut Version" as edition


the other movies of this collection only have "Lionsgate Limited" as editon, because that it's what its called, but this edition has a bit more on the cover
https://lionsgatelimited.com/products/american-psycho-25th-anniversary-4k-collectors-edition-corrected?variant=43954025594991